18 Apr Russell Barkley Responds to NYT ADHD Article
Brooklyn Letters
1139 Prospect Avenue, Brooklyn
-
We would highly recommend Ally! Our son always asks about her, so very thankful to Brooklyn Letters for introducing us.
~ Emily, mom of Brooklyn 2 year old -
Nicole has been an amazing therapist!! She played a tremendous role in our daughter’s speech progress and overall development. She has come such a long way and we are so happy with the therapy she received!
-
I cannot express how grateful and rewarding my experience with Brooklyn Letters has been. Her tutor Ms. Daria is so knowledgeable, amazing, kind and awesome. My daughter has made so much progress in Literacy and Math and it's all … More thanks to Ms. Daria. I know my daughter is sad that she can no longer work with Ms. Daria, as she looked forward to their sessions every week. Thank you again!
-
Excellent services, caring therapists.
-
Christina was absolutely wonderful. She went out of her way to win my son over and it worked. He looked forward to her visits and his speech improved so much under her care. She was super flexible and it’s clear she truly cares. We adore … More Christina and we’re going to miss her. Almost sad he improved so much! She’s simply amazing and we can’t say enough how great she is. I would recommend her services to anyone and everyone, without hesitation. Thank you so much for connecting us with her!
-
We could not be happier with the services Valerie provided! She is very thoughtful and knowledgeable and provided significant guidance to support our daughter's speech development outside of our scheduled sessions. She established … More a great working relationship with her, and she will definitely be missed! Your business model is amazing and it was an absolute pleasure working with Valerie. I've referred your organization and Valerie to the Executive Director of our daughter's school and friends/colleagues who are in need of speech therapy services.
-
We cannot say enough good things about Effie, the ASL teacher, who was so engaged and effective with our 2 year old daughter from the very first session! Effie gladly included our whole family in the sessions! Her expertise and fantastic … More personality gave our daughter a way to communicate that she was so desperately seeking. The coordinators at Brooklyn Letters were so helpful and communicative…I would highly recommend their services!
-
The company is great with outstanding customer service. They keep my horses protected. I have recommended them to other horses trainers as well that are going to get service early next year. Very professional an honest too. Respectfully … More submitted Christopher
-
Ron and Ken did a fantastic job with our security system today. Installed everything very quick. Both of them were very polite and asked us throughout if the installation met our needs. Simply fantastic!
-
I called Cornerstone Protection to get a Security system at a relatives out of state property, within a week it was installed! The installers worked with the client to help understand her new system and she was happy! Our relative said … More they were courteous, professional and patient! I highly recommend Cornerstone Protection for all of your security needs!
-
Had blink cameras; Car was broken into multiple times so I called CornerStone & they were able to install multiple cameras very quickly & for a reasonable price. I am so happy with the app & getting alerts that are not superfluous, … More like they were with Blink. Highly recommend CornerStone & the tech Ronnie.
-
Ron and Ken are great guys to work with.
Both were very knowledgeable and got our system back up and running.
Thanks to both for a job well done... -
Samantha Dalmas was fantastic! We saw her for a feeding therapy evaluation and while she doesn’t think my daughter needs more feeding therapy sessions at this time, but she gave me lots of tips to try. If my daughter's doctors want … More to see more progress at her next appointment, I wouldn’t hesitate to reach out to Samantha again.
-
Amazing assistance provided by Shannon today on my security system. I’m so grateful for your prompt, efficient, professional, and courteous service. Put me down as a customer for life!
-
One of the most painless experiences I've had. They came on time and was over the moon professional with still keeping a level of personability to it. The gentleman also went out of his way to say that my husband and Mines business … More was appreciated. Which is actually rare to be appreciated by such a great company. So thank you and we look forward to continuing services with this company.
-
I am so happy we decided to go with cornerstone. They were quick and efficient. Shannon and the installer we very friendly. We got a lot of equipment and it was still within our budget. 10/10 would definitely recommend! Thank you
-
Love the customer service and Shanon and his team go above and beyond for my restaurant. Couldn't of asked for a better security system and level of service that his team provides.
-
I have been using Cornerstone Protection service for over 5 years and I'm really happy with the service and state-of-the-art equipments and it's futures are so much in advance and friendly, I highly recommend Cornerstone Protection … More Service any and all business that need a security protection days and nights specially after business hours(Cornerstone Protection is perfect solution for your business). Owner of Cornerstone Protection is proactive with their customers and their equipments. Good experienced with Cornerstone Protection!!!
Kanu Patel -
We had a very positive experience with Alissa as a tutor for our pod of 5th grade boys from January - June 2020. She cared a lot about the boys and worked hard to create meaningful activities for them. The pod experience was invaluable … More for all of our families during a difficult year and we were so grateful to have found this partnership! We also want to appreciate Craig for helping to match us with a tutor on very short notice after we had cycled through a few folks who were not able to see the commitment through. Thanks for sticking with us!
-
Dusty was the exact person we needed to help our child finish out the school year. So grateful to him for the way he steadily encouraged her and helped her stay on track and organized. He is flexible, responsive to our needs/schedule as … More a family, and a delight to be with. We are also thankful that Craig at Themba Tutors really "gets it" and partnered us with such a wonderful tutor who was a great fit for our girl.
-
My child worked with Gillian D virtually for math enrichment. She is an excellent teacher. She took time to understand my child's specific learning style and provided tools that would be engaging. She was kind and empathetic- really … More made it her goal to connect with my child and build trust and rapport. My child started the school year with confidence and without the typically "brain-drain" that occurs over the summer, thanks to Gillian.
-
I am going into my second year as a Themba tutor. I have met so many great individuals while working for this company. Craig and the rest of the Themba team do such an excellent job picking and choosing Themba tutors that suit each client's … More individual needs! I look forward to meeting new tutors and clients in the 2021-2022 school year!
-
Our son started in a new high school, 100% remote, and was really struggling with Latin and Physics. I found Themba Tudors online and had an initial call with Craig, who was very knowledgeable, responsive, and found 2 amazing tutors for … More us. Both the Latin and the physics tutors were fantastic, connected with my son really well and helped him go from 'failing' grade to 'honors'! I will for sure continue using (and recommending!) Themba Tutors. Thank you, C, K, and W!
-
Brian is a fantastic executive functioning coach. Super helpful, flexible with hours, and tailored the experience to our needs.
-
Giulia Mercuri is a great Italian tutor! She was very responsive and accessible. Giulia put a ton of effort into preparing for each session and really helped our son with test preparation and projects. We are grateful that she was able … More to help, especially since our son did not receive any live teaching during COVID. We are happy that she was referred to us!
-
As an adult student diagnosed with a learning disability during grad school, I knew I needed help dealing with my Master's program's demanding workload. I was seriously considering dropping out when I was referred to Themba Tutors. … More I was paired up with a wonderful tutor, Julie, who was a total lifesaver. I learned many techniques that I can utilize in the future as I embark on the next phase of my career.
I can wholeheartedly say after working with Themba for two years that I would not have finished my program without this organization. And I am so thankful I selected them. -
We were introduced to a wonderful tutor: Mcedwyn. He and our son, a freshman in college, worked well together. As a result, our son’s grades significantly improved. The tutor taught our son subject content and various methods to effectively … More study for quizzes and exams. Our son was also taught time management and organization. My son’s experience with the tutor made the first year of college a less intimidating experience.
-
We have been with our tutor, Cailin Schiller, for two years, from 5th - 7th grade. She started as an executive functioning tutor with my daughter. From the start, she demonstrated a depth of expertise and a selective use of techniques skillfully … More adapted to my daughter’s ADHD and Math disability. Cailin made Math accessible and understandable to her in a way that even her teachers had not been able to do. She differentiated reading, writing and math tasks and assignments to tailor them to my daughter’s unique learning differences. Not only did it have an effect on her grades and her work efficiency, but she finally could do her work with less anxiety. Even my daughter’s teachers used Cailin’s guidance to modify their work with her. But most importantly, she became my daughter’s favorite resource. I can’t say how invaluable Cailin has been to my daughter’s progress and well-being. I’d recommend her a million times over. She is a gem.
-
Victoria is a superb tutor. She helped my high school age daughter with her writing. Victoria's skills as a tutor, as well as her sense of humor and her engaging personality went a long way with my daughter.
-
Themba Tutors provided a leaning specialist that was a perfect fit for my daughter. I told them what we were looking for and they delivered. Our tutor is responsive and flexible and makes it easy for my daughter to reach out to her own … More her own, which gives her an added sense of responsibility over her learning. As a therapist myself, I now regularly recommend Themba to my patients. A much needed and well provided service to the community!!
-
The tutors at Themba are fantastic! Caitlyn McNeill helped our son academically, but also with getting organized in every subject, which he so desperately needed. She offered great advice and useful strategies that helped our son become … More a more successful student. We are using Themba tutors again this year for our daughter. We're so happy to have been referred to them!
-
I'm so glad we were referred to Themba Tutors. After a great initial conversation to learn our needs, we were connected with an excellent tutor, Felicia, who is helping our high school daughter learn better organizational and executive … More skills. Highly recommended.
-
We had a wonderful experience with our tutor Micaela. She helped our son not only academically but at every level. We will be forever grateful to have her in our lives.
-
The tutors at Themba are fantastic! Caitlyn McNeill helped our son academically, but also with getting organized in every subject, which he so desperately needed. She offered great advice and useful strategies that helped our son become … More a more successful student. We are using Themba tutors again this year for our daughter. We're so happy to have been referred to them!
-
Paul Smith at Themba has been an exceptional tutor for my son, both in terms of teaching the subject matter and teaching how best to approach the process of learning math and executing assignments. We feel very fortunate to be working with … More Paul.
-
We were very lucky to have found Edwouine Swift, my son's therapist through Themba Tutors. Thomas is 12 years old, and it is extremely difficult to get him to write. Edwouine just works her magic with him, he adores her and is so … More eager to follow her guidance. I have no doubt she will be a positive driving force in his academic future.
RUSSELL BARKLEY’S ADHD RESPONSE TO PAUL TOUGH’S 2025 FEATURE
New York Times Magazine ADHD Article Corrections: Understanding the Controversy
In a detailed four-part video series, clinical psychologist and ADHD expert Dr. Russell Barkley critiques Paul Tough’s April 2025 New York Times Magazine article, arguing that it misrepresents the behavioral sciences, misleads readers about ADHD medication effectiveness, and fuels ADHD myths that can harm public trust in psychiatry.
Barkley’s response highlights the importance of distinguishing mental health science from media narratives that may distort findings. His analysis brings attention to corrections needed in ADHD reporting, particularly regarding stimulant medications and their role in managing symptoms for patients across the lifespan.
Economist Articles Connection
Barkley points out that the NYT article echoes themes found in two recent Economist pieces:
He sees this trend as part of a broader media narrative that downplays the seriousness of ADHD as a legitimate neurodevelopmental condition.
Part 1: Challenging the Foundation of the NYT Article
In Part 1 of his video series, Barkley critiques the article’s early sections, which reference:
- Dr. James Swanson’s evolving views on ADHD
- The landmark Multimodal Treatment Study of ADHD (MTA)
- ADHD prevalence rates reported by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC)
Part 2: The Same Old Myths Rehashed
Barkley opens Part 2 by correcting a minor misstatement from Part 1 regarding the CDC survey question. Though he acknowledges the mistake, he maintains his point that such data likely overstates actual ADHD prevalence.
He then tackles recurring myths in the NYT article — some recycled from anti-psychiatry groups like the Church of Scientology. Key debunked claims include:
- Rising prescriptions reflect better recognition, not overuse.
- ADHD meds aren’t based on flawed brain repair theories — they’re used because they work.
- Environmental factors aren’t a new discovery — they’ve been part of ADHD research for 50+ years.
- DSM isn’t a rigid medical straightjacket — it’s a guide based on evidence, and the use of “often” in symptom criteria adds clinical flexibility.
- Dimensional traits don’t disprove ADHD — many disorders exist on a spectrum and are still medically recognized.
Barkley calls this a case of “journalism by omission,” where context is deliberately left out, misleading readers and undermining scientific consensus.
ADHD Newsletter Summary: What You Need to Know
Headline Points:
- ADHD (attention deficit hyperactivity disorder) is a neurodevelopmental disorder, not a personality trait or behavior.
- Stimulant medications like Ritalin and Adderall have a positive effect when used appropriately.
- ADHD affects academic achievement, behavior, and cognitive ability, especially in children and adolescents.
- Doctors and clinicians emphasize early intervention and sustained support as essential.
- Clinical psychologists, psychiatrists, and professors of psychiatry agree: ADHD should be taken seriously and treated accordingly.
Part 3: Selective Science and Ignored Evidence
In Part 3, Barkley continues his breakdown by addressing more scientific inaccuracies:
- “Arbitrary” Diagnosis Cut-offs: Barkley says clinical thresholds may be arbitrary, but they’re essential for determining who needs support.
- Biomarkers Debate: ADHD lacks a definitive biomarker — but so do all mental disorders. Barkley notes substantial genetic and neuroimaging evidence still supports ADHD’s neurobiological basis.
- Missing the 2021 Consensus Statement: The NYT article mentions the 2002 consensus while ignoring the more recent, robust 2021 statement that outlines over 200 evidence-based conclusions.
- Neurological Evidence Ignored: Barkley cites hundreds of neuroimaging studies showing brain structure and connectivity differences in ADHD patients.
- Treatment Advancements Dismissed: Barkley calls out the article’s claim that treatments haven’t changed in 90 years — listing new medications, delivery systems, behavioral interventions, and coaching strategies.
- Academic Achievement Argument: The article argues meds don’t improve grades. Barkley counters that ADHD is a disorder of performance, not intelligence — meds help people demonstrate what they already know.
- Positive Outcomes Ignored: Barkley lists benefits in driving safety, employment, college success, behavior, and reduced injuries — none of which are mentioned in the article.
Part 4: A Misleading Narrative
In his final video, Barkley takes aim at what he sees as the most harmful misrepresentations:
- Long-term medication effects: Claims that benefits “fade” over time misread the MTA study design.
- Height suppression: Acknowledged, but Barkley says it’s minimal and outweighed by treatment benefits.
- Psychosis risk: Misleading — the study cited was retrospective, not based on general ADHD patients.
- The idea that meds offer no long-term benefits: Barkley says this is a mischaracterization of how chronic disorders are managed.
- Symptom fluctuation: Even if symptoms change, most individuals still meet criteria over time.
- Category vs. dimension: Barkley calls this critique trivial — clinicians already rate severity within categories.
- Involving kids in med decisions: Barkley opposes letting children decide on treatment for long-term health risks.
- Environment-only treatment: While environmental supports matter, Barkley says eliminating meds isn’t realistic.
Behavioral Science Breakdown: The MTA Study in Context
The Multimodal Treatment Study of ADHD (MTA), a key reference in the article, is used to support claims that stimulant tolerance limits long-term benefits.
Barkley counters that:
- The study’s treatment groups became mixed after 14 months, invalidating later-stage comparisons.
- In the controlled phase, stimulant medications and combined interventions outperformed other approaches.
Child ADHD Rates: Are CDC Statistics Inflated?
He cites meta-analyses and NIMH data showing more conservative and rigorously established prevalence estimates. Tough’s article cites CDC statistics stating:
- Over 7 million American adolescents and children have ADHD.
- 23% of high school students, especially 17-year-old boys, have received a diagnosis.
Barkley disputes this, noting:
- Many of these are based on parent-reported symptoms, not clinical assessments.
- Peer-reviewed studies suggest a more accurate prevalence of 5–7% in children and 3–5% in adults.
- He stresses the importance of accurate, time-sensitive diagnoses — emphasizing that early time diagnoses can improve treatment success and prevent complications later in life.
Does ADHD Medications Work? Examining the Effects
Barkley reinforces that stimulant medications like Adderall and Ritalin:
- Improve attention, impulse control, and executive function
- Support academic and behavioral outcomes
- Carry side effects, but those are manageable with medical oversight
- Should be used in tandem with therapy and accommodations when possible
According to this article, which centers on the long-term effectiveness of Ritalin, highlighting the MTA study, which initially showed short-term improvement in attention among children with ADHD. However, by 36 months, the benefits diminished, and children on the drug showed similar symptoms to those who never took it. The article also questions the rigidity of ADHD as a diagnosis, noting that symptoms fluctuate over time, there’s no clear biological marker, and many children without initial diagnoses later met the criteria — suggesting a more nuanced, context-dependent understanding of attention issues.
Other Interventions: Beyond Stimulant Medications
Barkley supports a multimodal treatment plan:
- Medications
- Behavioral therapy
- Environmental accommodations
- Educational interventions
He also highlights the value of early behavioral support — in homes, schools, and preschools — as a prevention strategy to reduce severity later in life.
ADHD and Behavior in Public Discourse
Barkley critiques growing narratives suggesting ADHD is:
- Merely a personality style
- A temporary childhood phase
- Better handled by changing society than by treating individuals
He believes these framings confuse caregivers and minimize the struggles of those with genuine ADHD. He urges readers to turn to clinical resources and consensus statements — not opinion pieces — for evidence-based guidance.
Final Thoughts
Dr. Russell Barkley’s four-part response to the New York Times Magazine article isn’t just about correcting facts — it’s about defending the integrity of mental health science. He argues that ADHD is too often misunderstood in public discourse, with media pieces like this one reviving old myths, misusing research, and downplaying decades of evidence.
His critique reminds us of a simple truth: ADHD is a well-documented, neurodevelopmental disorder that requires informed, individualized care — not ideological debate. Oversimplifying the science or ignoring context does more than confuse the public — it risks undermining treatment, delaying diagnosis, and stigmatizing the people who live with ADHD every day.
If the conversation around ADHD is going to evolve, it has to start with evidence — not headlines.
The following two tabs change content below.
Craig Selinger
Owner at Themba Tutors
Meet Craig Selinger, the passionate owner behind Themba Tutors, a renowned practice specializing in executive function coaching and tutoring. Together with his team of multidisciplinary professionals, they bring their extensive knowledge to numerous locations: Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island, Bronx, Westchester, Long Island, New Jersey, and Connecticut, as well as offering remote services. As a licensed speech-language pathologist in the state of NY, executive functioning coach, and educational specialist with an impressive track record spanning over two decades, Craig has professionally assisted thousands of families. Craig's proficiency encompasses a wide spectrum of areas, including language-related learning challenges such as reading, writing, speaking, and listening. He is also well-versed in executive functioning, ADHD/ADD, and various learning disabilities. Beyond his clinical and coaching work, Craig is also a published author on Amazon, where he shares practical strategies that extend his expertise to a broader audience. What truly distinguishes Craig and his team is their unwavering commitment to delivering comprehensive support. By actively collaborating with the most esteemed professionals within the NYC metropolitan region – from neuropsychologists to mental health therapists and allied health experts – they create a network of expertise.
Latest posts by Craig Selinger (see all)
- Making Sense Of Sensory Triggers And Helpful Tools - February 3, 2026
- How Music Can Help Ease Anxiety In Children - February 3, 2026
- Hyperfocus and ADHD: Strength or Struggle? - January 27, 2026
No Comments